34 pens · 5 makers · 1920s to today
A Parker 51 or a Pelikan from the 1950s can still be a daily writer, if the part that holds the ink is sound. That part is usually the problem. Sacs harden, diaphragms split and cork seals shrink. Every pen here has its own page, with the imprints that identify it, the filler it uses and the questions to put to the seller.
The filler is the part of an old pen most likely to need work, so it’s the first thing to check. Here they are from the easiest to live with to the ones that almost always need restoring.

Parker · 1948–1969
AerometricAero-metric filler, 1948 to 1969
Post-war golden age
$90–$260 typical ask

Pelikan · 1982–present
PistonGreen striped, old-style trim, 1982 to 1997
Modern
$290–$350 typical ask

Sheaffer · 1952–1959
Snorkel and TouchdownPalladium silver Triumph point, plastic cap
Post-war golden age
$110–$170 typical ask

Montblanc · 1952–present
PistonPrecious resin, 1980s
Modern
$575–$650 typical ask

Pilot · 1992–present
Cartridge and converter14K size 5 nib, cartridge or converter
Modern
$130–$150 typical ask

Parker · 1937–1948
VacumaticMid-size Vacumatic, 1937 to 1948
Pre-war and wartime
$160–$210 typical ask
Sell to us
Tell us what you have, what the barrel and nib say and whether it fills, with a few photos and your price. Our pen expert will get back to you quickly with a cash offer if it’s a fit. No listing to write, no fees.